When it comes to the events of the past week, many other people have already made similar points to those that I want to make, and that has led me to ask why I need to say the same thing. If I’m going to be serious about this undertaking (which, I need to remember, I feel called to do by God), I need to start acting like a blogger, not a guy who just “has a blog.” Plus, I need to stand up and be counted. I can’t be silent, even if some of some of what I say strikes me as pretty obvious and repetitive. Not all of this relates directly to my faith, but as a person of faith, my opinions in these matters are hopefully shaped by wisdom revealed to me by God.
For the tl;dr crowd (since I wrote more than 2,500 words), here are the high points:
- I’m fine with relocating Confederate statues, monuments, etc. to a more museum-like setting instead of a setting that glorifies the subjects.
- I reject the twin evils of racism and hate, and I reject those who spread them. I especially reject those who twistedly use the cross – the cross my Savior died on – in an attempt to justify a hate-filled, white supremacist view of the world.
- I tried to warn everyone about Donald Trump 18 months ago. (I know I’m not alone on that one.)
- This isn’t about politics. This is about taking an honest look around us, perhaps noticing things we didn’t notice before, and deciding what’s right.
- I’m a lifelong Virginian who has lived in five different towns around the commonwealth, but more than any other place, I consider Charlottesville to be “my town” (again, not alone in that sentiment). Reading about what happened there Friday and Saturday moved me to tears.
Whoever lets black be white and evil good for the sake of outward calm does not deserve peace and is putting his head in the sand. But whoever knows at all times the difference between good and evil and does not doubt it, however great the triumph of evil seems to be, has laid the first stone for the overcoming of evil. — Helmuth James von Moltke, Letters to Freya 1939-1945
And now it’s time for the deeper dive.
I’ll start with the legacy of the Confederacy because that’s how the Charlottesville tragedy started. The city recently renamed Lee Park to Emancipation Park. There is a statue of Robert E. Lee in the park, and the city plans to remove it. Hence, the “Unite the Right” rally planned for this past Saturday.
Before I deal with that, though, some background: I grew up in central Virginia, not even an hour from Appomattox. Civil War battlefields are everywhere in Virginia, and going to Appomattox was a standard elementary school field trip. The Confederate cause was not necessarily glorified, but I definitely grew up thinking that Lee was a fine man who just ended up on the losing side. Why else would we have Washington & Lee University in Lexington, or Lee Chapel at VMI, or Robert E. Lee High School in Staunton, right?
Now I live in Richmond, and of course here we have Monument Avenue, where extremely large memorials of Lee, J.E.B. Stuart, Jefferson Davis, Stonewall Jackson, and Matthew Maury stretch over the span of a few blocks. Recently, the mayor appointed a commission to study the best way to “add context” to the statues while leaving them in place. I suppose “context” could be added by creating informational exhibits in the surrounding intersections – presumably to provide a complete picture of who these men were, why the statues were erected in the first place, and why Virginia chooses to keep them there today. On Wednesday, in light of recent events, the mayor added removal/relocation to the list of options he wants the commission to consider.
One of the things I never, ever thought about growing up is why the statues were there, or why any Confederate memorial existed, for that matter. They were just there, and I never had any reason to question them being there. Now that I’ve read a little more about it, though – and I’ve seen this expressed on Facebook several times recently – it’s clear that most Confederate monuments were erected as a great big middle finger to black people and to the federal government. Most of them were established as the Jim Crow era cranked up in the early 1900s, and one final wave of them came in protest of the civil rights era in the 1960s.
Given that background, I get why people on their daily commutes don’t want to see these reminders of whites’ efforts to subjugate, intimidate, and commit violence against blacks. I don’t want to “erase history”, which is what the Confederate heritage types would have us believe. (As an aside, you should know I have plenty of that heritage. Two of my great-great-granddaddies fought for the Confederacy. And one of my great-great-great-granddaddies was taken as a prisoner of war when the Union army captured Saltville, VA.) But we can re-examine our history. Those memorials on Monument Avenue come across as glorifying those men and their misguided cause, and when thousands of people are driving by them every day, most of them aren’t going to stop what they’re doing to check out exhibits that provide “context”.
So why not move them? Move them to the grounds of a Civil War museum, where the only people who will see them are the people who want to see them, and where there is plenty of room to provide a full picture of the Confederacy, its aftermath (Jim Crow, massive resistance, etc.), and how these memorials came to be. Maybe I’m being naive or simplistic, but we shouldn’t erase the ugly parts of our history. I don’t want to make Confederate memorials vanish. But as I’ve seen said by multiple people on Facebook, the place for them is a museum, not a pedestal.
Back to our “Unite the Right” friends in C’ville: These were not a bunch of Civil War re-enactors who like to play dress-up and just feel a bit sad that a piece of Civil War history might be removed from a park. These were hate-filled white supremacists – when you march around shouting things like “Blood and soil”, “You will not replace us”, and “Jews will not replace us”, you’re not talking about the right way to remember the Civil War. You’re talking about white power. You’re talking about hate for anyone who doesn’t look like you or believe the same things you do. One demonstrator told a reporter that Charlottesville “is run by Jewish communists and criminal n——.” Another one told a counter-protester, “I hope you get raped by a n—–.” (For some background on why Jews get brought into this whole thing (since most of them are, you know, white) – read this.)
So yeah, as a Christian, I reject these guys. I reject their ideology. I reject any attempt by them to claim any Christian basis for what they believe. As a Southern Baptist leader said, their beliefs “are anti-Christ and satanic to the core.”
He may not be satanic to the core, but President Trump has not covered himself in glory with his statements over the past few days. I’m not going to rehash everything here – there are literally thousands of news articles out there about his mis-handling of this situation.
Contrast Trump with times in U.S. history when we have looked to our president for leadership and reassurance. Some great speeches live on: Washington’s Farewell Address; Lincoln’s Gettysburg Address; Kennedy’s pledge to go to the moon. A more recent speech that most of us watched was George W. Bush’s address on the evening of 9/11/01. His most memorable line was probably, “If you’re not with us, you’re against us.” A turn on that phrase captures where our current president has failed miserably: “If you’re not against white supremacists, you’re with them.” Yes, I know Trump finally condemned racist groups when he read a prepared statement Monday, but his off-the-cuff statements both before and after that prepared statement speak much more loudly.
Plenty of the “Unite the Right” guys were looking for a fight last weekend, and unfortunately, some of the counter-protesters were happy to oblige. So while Trump’s comments about violence on “many sides” is technically correct, it’s correct only at the kindergarten schoolyard level – “Hey, they were doing it, too! They should get in trouble, too!” Please. While a few counter-protesters may have been the first to attack, it’s pretty clear there were plenty more instances where it was the white supremacists initiating violence. The fact that some counter-protesters may have started some skirmishes doesn’t validate the views of the people they attacked – it doesn’t work that way. And I didn’t see any counter-protesters getting in their cars and mowing down people in the street.
I don’t know why Trump says what he says; I’m not inside his head. Maybe he’s a racist. Maybe he’s terrible at articulating what he really thinks. Maybe he knows he needs votes from David Duke and his ilk. Maybe all of the above. What I do know, though, is the solution to this mess isn’t going to come from Trump or any other politician.
This is not a time for politics, and it is not a time for politicians to try to score points for their parties. This is not a time for Republicans to get on the “whatabout” train and remind us that while the white supremacists are awful, what about that time the New Black Panthers were at a polling place? What about that time protesters broke windows at Trump’s inauguration? What about Obama refusing to say “Islamist terrorists”? What about … you get the idea. Yes, it may be true that the “liberal media” gave some of those people a pass or didn’t cover the episode adequately – but that doesn’t mean a widespread outcry against what happened on Friday and Saturday is wrong or unfair. I understand that the media’s (perceived) glossing over some of these situations can fuel the resentment felt by others, but that doesn’t excuse the kind of thing that happened in Charlottesville. Go grind your axes and nurse your grudges somewhere else, because at this moment, they’re irrelevant to the fact that we all should be standing firmly against hate.
So where does the solution come from? At the risk of being simplistic again, it comes from each one of us. We examine our actions and thoughts. We teach our children not to be racist – man, that sounds so obvious, but it’s important. We call out racism when we see it – whether it be a co-worker’s remark, a family member’s opinion, or anything else. We make clear that it is not OK.
Everything in the previous paragraph goes double for my fellow Christians. Jesus said the second-greatest commandment is, “Love your neighbor as yourself.” To state yet another obvious point: Racism is hate. It is the opposite of love. Jesus didn’t offer any qualifiers – our “neighbors” are all around us, and they include all the people who don’t have the same skin tone as you. The president of the Southern Baptist Theological Seminary wrote this letter Monday while he was in Berlin, where they have some firsthand experience with dangerous notions of ethnic superiority. The key passage:
We must see claims of racial superiority – and mainly that means claims of white superiority – as heresy.
That is not a word we use casually. Heresy leads to a denial of the gospel of Jesus Christ, the eclipse of the living God as revealed in the Bible. A claim of white superiority is not merely wrong, and not merely deadly. It is a denial of the glory of God in creating humanity – every single human being – in his own image. It is a rejection of God’s glory in creating a humanity of different skin pigmentation. It is a misconstrual of God’s judgment and glory in creating different ethnicities.
Most urgently, it is a rejection of the gospel of Christ – the great good news of God’s saving purpose in the atonement accomplished by Christ. A claim of racial superiority denies our common humanity, our common sinfulness, our common salvation through faith in Christ, and God’s purpose to create a common new humanity in Christ.
You cannot preach the gospel of Jesus Christ and hold to any notion of racial superiority. It is impossible.
The obligation doesn’t fall solely on Christians as individuals, either. The church must step up as an institution. Churches, particularly those in the South, don’t have the greatest history when it comes to race relations. This piece in the Atlantic covers a lot of ground on churches and race.
Where I grew up, we had white churches and black churches – I remember it striking me as odd, but as with other things, that was just the way it was, and I didn’t question it. There was a “black” Baptist church practically right across the road from my house and a “white” Baptist church a mile down the road. (I went to a United Methodist church, and everyone there was white.) I rode the school bus with friends who went to the two Baptist churches, and the arrangement didn’t seem to bother anybody.
Now, the fact that my current church is mostly white makes me a bit uncomfortable. Not uncomfortable in the sense that I think it’s wrong, but I just wonder why we still have this division – there is even a “black” church in the same general area with the same name as the church I attend. History leaves us with strange outcomes sometimes. For comparison, when I lived in the DC suburbs, I belonged to a Baptist church that was the most diverse church I’ve ever been to – white, black, Hispanic, African, immigrants – everybody.
So what does a still-divided church do? One passage from the Atlantic article hit me:
Many people within the church are frustrated with what they see as passivity in the face of bigotry. In the same way that Muslims are often expected to take responsibility for those on their fringes who commit violent acts of terrorism, people demanded that white Christians account for the violent racists who claim to share their faith.
I cannot account for it. (And I was disappointed that the pastor I listened to on Sunday did not even mention the events in Charlottesville.) My best guess is that these bigots have taken God’s word and twisted it to the point of being unrecognizable, and now they use it as a weapon against anyone not like them. That is not Christianity. There is no room for debate.
Finally, I come to Charlottesville – my town. I lived there two separate times for a total of more than seven years. I made memories and friends for life – friends from different parts of the country, friends of different faiths, and friends of different colors. It is not a perfect place by any means – that place doesn’t exist on Earth. But it is a wonderful place, a diverse place, a place where all kinds of people come to live, to learn, and to love.
I know that free speech – even when it’s hateful speech – is important. You can question the wisdom of how the local government and authorities handled things last weekend, but let’s not question the wisdom of the First Amendment. Even though I understand that intellectually, it’s a lot easier to ignore hate when it’s somewhere else. But not in Charlottesville. Not in my backyard. Not at my school. Not in MY TOWN. The photographs from Friday night – of the Unite the Right crowd on the Lawn, of them surrounding a statue of Thomas Jefferson as a small group of people (including students) defied them – are impossible for me to forget. I couldn’t have imagined that kind of thing happening when I was a student, but here we are.
The UVa community received multiple emails about what happened – from the school president, from the rector, and others. Law school alumni received an email from our dean, and she pointed to words from Thurgood Marshall:
I wish I could say that racism and prejudice were only distant memories. We must dissent from the indifference. We must dissent from the apathy. We must dissent from the fear, the hatred and the mistrust…. We must dissent because America can do better, because America has no choice but to do better.
Listen up, Richard Spencer. You, too, Jason Kessler. I dissent. I’m not going to fight you with batons, shields, or tear gas. I’m going to put on the full armor of God, and I’m going to live a life that bit by bit, piece by piece, and person by person will defeat everything you stand for.
Who is wise and understanding among you? Let them show it by their good life, by deeds done in the humility that comes from wisdom. — James 3:13